In a review for Entertainment Weekly, Ken Tucker states that, compared to the faster paced Where in the World Is Carmen Sandiego?, "Shining Time Station wants to slow things down; it's an old- fashioned show that creates a gentle, lulling atmosphere to convince children that life is fun and that trains are the way to travel.
Also, before the executive producer Rick Siggelkow went to work at the BBC, he was planning a Shining Time Station movie. For reasons unexplained, the movie was canceled.
A local named Horace Schemer (simply called Schemer by his friends) runs the station's arcade and is always finding new ways to make more money or to protect his arcade. He serves as the series' comic relief. Schemer thinks that strange goings-on in the station happen because the station is haunted. His catch phrases include "Genius time" (for when he has an idea), "Schemer's system of success" (for when he wants to impress his friends) and "This place is haunted". Starting in the second season, Schemer would sometimes be aided in his schemes by his nephew, Schemee.
Harry's granddaughter, Tanya, and Stacy's nephew, Matt, also visit the station occasionally. In the second season, three new children visit the station: Harry's granddaughter, Kara; Stacy's nephew, Dan; and a new girl named Becky.
Other visitors to the station include various townspeople, such as socialite and gossip Midge Smoot, farmer Ginny Johnson, general store proprietor Barton Winslow, bus driver Felix Perez, Shining Time's mayor Osgood Bob Flopdinger (referred to as the mayor of East Shemp in his initial appearance), and J.B. King, Esq., the superintendent of the Indian Valley Railroad.
There is a jukebox inside the arcade that houses a band that perform for the nickels that are dropped inside. The band consists of Didi the drummer, cowboy twin brothers Tex and Rex who together play between them one guitar larger than them, Grace who plays bass guitar, and Tito the leader who plays the piano and collects the nickels they accumulate.
Mr. Conductor is a tiny man who lives in a switch house inside the station's mural and tells the stories of Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends to the kids. He can teleport in a cloud of his magic gold dust.
| Song | Episode(s) |
|---|---|
| I've Been Working on the Railroad | A Place Unlike Any Other |
| Camptown Races | Does It Bite? |
| Railroad Corral | Pitching in And Helping Out |
| Abilene | Agree to Disagree |
| Pop Goes the Weasel | Whistle While You Work |
| A Railroaders Bride I'll Be | Two Old Hands |
| The Wreck of Old '97 | Happy Accidents |
| The Train Is A Comin' | Ring In The Old |
| The Desperado | Finders Keepers |
| Union Train | Just Wild About Harry's Workshop |
| Oh! Susanna | Promises, Promises |
| Jesse James | Word's Out |
| Casey Jones | Too Many Cooks |
| Red River Valley | Mapping It Out |
| Clementine | Things That Go Ga-Hooga! in the Night |
| Little Black Train | Is This the End? |
| Midnight Special | Scare Dares |
| Mama Don't Allow | Oh, What a Tangled Web |
| Nine Hundred Miles | The Magic is Believing |
| Arkansas Traveler | Win, Lose or Draw |
| Erie Canal | Sweet and Sour |
| Cosher Bailey's Engine | Achoo! |
| Home on the Range | A Dog's Life |
| Take Me Out to the Ballgame | Field Day & Second Chances |
| Sweet Betsy from Pike | Wrong Track |
| Cumberland Gap | Washout |
| John Henry | Crackpot |
| My Bonnie Lies Over the Ocean | Nickle in a Pickle |
| She'll Be Coming Round the Mountain | Stop the Press |
| I Dream of Jeanie | He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not |
| This Train | Double Trouble |
| Chattanooga Choo Choo | Is Anybody There? |
| The Railroad Cars Are Coming | All's Fair |
| Celito Lindo | Becky Makes a Wish |
| Polly Wolly Doodle | Schemer Alone |
| Jamaican Farewell | Bully for Mr. Conductor |
| Five Hundred Miles | Stacy Cleans Up |
| Strollin' Through the Park | Schemer's Robot |
| Get on Board | Billy Saves the Day |
| We Gather Together | Billy's Party |
| Turkey in the Straw | Fortune Teller Schemer |
| Crawdad | Schemer Goes Camping |
| Danny Boy | Mr. Conductor's Evil Twin |
| Patriotic Medley | Mr. Conductor's 4th of July |
| Lullaby Medley | Stacy Forgets Her Name |
| Old Joe Clark | Schemer's Special Club |
| No Business Like Show Business | Mr. Conductor's Movie |
| Waltzing Matilda | Mysterious Stranger |
| Michael Row Your Boat Ashore | Dan's Big Race |
| Beautiful Dreamer | Mr. Conductor's Big Sleepwalk |
| Cowboy Medley | How The Station Got Its Name |
| Freight Train Blues | Mr. Conductor Gets Left Out |
| Cannonball Blues | The Mayor Run For Re-Election |
| Engine 143 | Bad Luck Day At Shining Time Station |
| Riddle Song | Dance Crazy |
| This Old Man | The Joke's On Schemer |
| Old Dan Tucker | ''Stacy Says No! |
| Lonestar Trail Medley | Once Upon A Time |
| Buffalo Gals Medley | Once Upon A Time |
| What's New Pussycat? | Once Upon A Time |
| Christmas Time At The Railway Station | Tis A Gift |
| Jingle Bells | Tis A Gift |
| Over The River And Through The Woods | Tis A Gift |
| If My Friends Could See Me Now | One Of The Family |
| Long, Long Ago | One Of The Family |
| This Land Is Your Land | One Of The Family |
| Down in the Valley | Second Chances |
| Skip To My Lou Medley | Second Chances |
| The Lovely Ohio | Queen For A Day |
| Greensleeves/Scarbarough Fair | Queen For A Day |
| Mrs. Murphy's Chowder | Queen For A Day |
| # | Title | Thomas story 1 | Thomas story 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A Place Unlike Any Other | Thomas Gets Tricked | Edward Helps Out |
| 2 | Does it Bite? | Come Out, Henry! | Henry to the Rescue |
| 3 | And the Band Played Off | A Big Day for Thomas | Trouble for Thomas |
| 4 | Pitching In and Helping Out | Thomas Saves the Day | James Learns a Lesson |
| 5 | Show and Yell | Foolish Freight Cars | A Proud Day for James |
| 6 | Faith, Hope and Anxiety | Thomas and the Conductor | Thomas Goes Fishing |
| 7 | Agree to Disagree | Terence the Tractor | Thomas and Bertie's Great Race |
| 8 | Whistle While You Work | Tenders and Turntables | Trouble in the Shed |
| 9 | Two Old Hands | Percy Runs Away | Thomas Comes to Breakfast |
| 10 | Happy Accidents | Henry's Special Coal | The Flying Kipper |
| 11 | Ring in the Old | Toby the Tram Engine | Thomas Breaks the Rules |
| 12 | Impractical Jokes | A Cow on the Line | Old Iron |
| 13 | Finders Keepers | Double Trouble | James in a Mess |
| 14 | Just Wild About Harry's Workshop | Duck Takes Charge | Percy Proves a Point |
| 15 | Promises, Promises | Better Late Than Never | Pop Goes the Diesel |
| 16 | Words Out | Diesel's Devious Deed | A Close Shave for Duck |
| 17 | Too Many Cooks | Gordon Takes a Dip | Down the Mine |
| 18 | Mapping it Out | The Runaway | Percy Takes a Plunge |
| 19 | Things That Go Gahooga in the Night | Percy's Ghostly Trick | Woolly Bear |
| 20 | Is This the End? | Saved from Scrap | A New Friend for Thomas |
| # | Title | Thomas story 1 | Thomas story 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 21 | 'Tis a Gift | TV: Terence the Tractor VHS: Thomas' Christmas Party | TV: Thomas' Christmas Party VHS: Thomas & The Missing Christmas Tree |
| # | Title | Thomas story 1 | Thomas story 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22 | Scare Dares | Percy's Ghostly Trick | Thomas, Percy and the Dragon |
| 23 | Oh, What a Tangled Web | Diesel's Devious Deed | No Joke For James |
| 24 | The Magic is Believing | Old Iron | Edward's Exploit |
| 25 | Win, Lose or Draw | Double Trouble | Gordon and the Famous Visitor |
| 26 | Sweet and Sour | Donald and Douglas | The Deputation |
| 27 | Achoo! | Trust Thomas | Whistles and Sneezes |
| 28 | A Dog's Life | James in a Mess | The Trouble with Mud |
| 29 | Field Day | Percy Proves a Point | Thomas and Bertie's Great Race |
| 30 | Wrong Track | Thomas Saves the Day | Down the Mine |
| 31 | Washout | Bertie's Chase | Percy's Promise |
| 32 | Crackpot | Woolly Bear | Henry's Forest |
| 33 | Yabba, Yabba, Yabba | Pop Goes the Diesel | Diesel Does It Again |
| 34 | Nickel in a Pickle | Thomas Comes to Breakfast | Thomas Gets Bumped |
| 35 | Stop the Press | Percy and the Signal | A Big Day for Thomas |
| 36 | He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not | Thomas, Percy and the Mail Train | |
| 37 | Double Trouble | The Diseasel | Donald's Duck |
| 38 | Is Anybody There? | Thomas Goes Fishing | A Scarf for Percy |
| 39 | Do I Hear? | Mavis | Toby's Tightrope |
| 40 | Jingle, Jingle, Jingle | Time for Trouble | Trouble for Thomas |
| 41 | All's Fair | Edward, Trevor and the Really Useful Party | |
| # | Title | Thomas story 1 | Thomas story 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 42 | Becky Makes a Wish | All at Sea | ||
| 43 | Schemer Alone | Percy, James and the Fruitful Day | ||
| 44 | Bully for Mr. Conductor | Bulgy | ||
| 45 | Stacy Cleans Up | James Goes Buzz Buzz | ||
| 46 | Schemer's Robot | Tenders and Turntables | Trouble in the Shed | |
| 47 | Billy Saves the Day | A New Friend for Thomas | ||
| 48 | Billy's Party | Thomas and Percy's Mountain Adventure | ||
| 49 | Fortune Teller Schemer | Thomas and the Conductor | A Cow on the Line | |
| 50 | Billy's Runaway Train | A Close Shave for Duck | The Runaway | |
| 51 | Schemer Goes Camping | Percy Takes the Plunge | ||
| 52 | Mr. Conductor's Evil Twin | Heroes | ||
| 53 | Bad Luck Day at Shining Time Station | Gordon Takes a Dip | ||
| 54 | Mr. Conductor's 4th of July | Escape | ||
| 55 | Stacy Forgets Her Name | Thomas Gets Tricked | ||
| 56 | Schemer's Special Club | Oliver Owns Up | ||
| 57 | Mr. Conductor's Movie | Tender Engines | ||
| 58 | The Joke's on Schemer | Daisy | Wrong Road | |
| 59 | Dance Crazy | Percy Runs Away | Percy's Predicament | |
| 60 | Mysterious Stranger | Come Out, Henry! | Henry to the Rescue | |
| 61 | Dan's Big Race | Henry's Special Coal | The Flying Kipper | |
| 62 | Mr. Conductor Gets Left Out | One Good Turn | A Proud Day for James | |
| 63 | Mr. Conductor's Big Sleepwalk | Saved from Scrap | Better Late Than Never | |
| 64 | The Mayor Runs for Re-Election | James Learns a Lesson | Foolish Freight Cars | |
| 65 | Stacy Says No! | Edward Helps Out | Duck Takes Charge | |
| 66 | How the Station Got Its Name | Toby the Tram Engine | Thomas Breaks the Rules |
| # | Title | Thomas story 1 | Thomas story 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Once Upon a Time | Rusty to the Rescue | Thomas & Stepney |
| 2 | Second Chances | Granpuff | Sleeping Beauty |
| 3 | One of the Family | Toad Stands By | Thomas & the Special Letter |
| 4 | Queen For a Day | Thomas Meets the Queen | Special Attraction |
| # | Title | Story 1 | Story 2 | Story 3 | Story 4 | Story 5 | Song |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Paint the Town Red | Come Out, Henry! | Fish | Whistles and Sneezes | Henry & the Elephant | Bulldog | Let's Have a Race |
| 2 | Splish, Splash, Splosh | Passengers and Polish | Gallant Old Engine | Bertie's Chase | Peter Sam & the Refreshment Lady | You Can't Win | Gone Fishing |
| 3 | Missing Whistles | Bulls' Eyes | Train Stops Play | Percy's Ghostly Trick | Thomas, Percy & the Dragon | Special Funnel | Really Useful Engine |
| 4 | Wildlife | Four Little Engines | Daisy | Saved From Scrap | Rusty Helps Peter Sam | Percy's Predicament | Toby |
| 5 | For the Birds | A Bad Day for Sir Handel | Percy Proves a Point | Bowled Out | The Diseasel | Steamroller | Don't Judge a Book By Its Cover |
| 6 | Wish You Were Here | Thomas, Percy & The Mail Train | Mind That Bike | Rock N Roll | Home at Last | Thomas & The Special Letter | Island Song |