By today's standards, compared with examples such as Najidah and Raphael House this shelter at Blackfriars would be considered inadequate and callous toward these individuals. However, at the time this was considered a well meaning, inexpensive, and compassionate attempt to deal with the relatively new phenomena of homelessness. The Salvation Army believed these shelters provided relief from the harsh London winters and provided new devoted followers to the Christian faith. Others, such as Professor Howard Sercombe of the University of Strathclyde have argued that such institutions were more likely to have been designed in order to control the homeless, or at the very best - a compassionate response to the harsh "moving on" laws of the time, which made it illegal for people to remain, vagrantly upon the streets.