Modus ponendo tollens (Latin:
mode that denies by affirming) is a valid
rule of inference, sometimes abbreviated
MPT. It is closely related to
Modus ponens and
modus tollens. It is usually described as having the form:
- Not both A and B
- A
- Therefore, not B
For example:
- Ann and Bill cannot both win the race.
- Ann won the race
- So, Bill cannot win the race
As E.J. Lemmon describes it:"Modus ponendo tollens is the principle that, if the negation of a conjunction holds and also one of its conjuncts, then the negation of its other conjunct holds.
In logic notation this can be represented as:
-
-
-
Other mathematical and logical symbols may be used to present this same form, such as:
- ~(A • B)
- A
- ~B
It has also been described as having the following alternative forms:
- Either A is B or A is C
- A is B
- Therefore, A is not C
| - Either A is B or C is D
- A is B
- Therefore, C is not D
| - Either A or B is C
- A is C
- Therefore, B is not C
|
References