Ohio is one of the least successful states at Miss Teen USA, and has only placed twice. Most importantly, Allie LaForce won the Miss Teen USA crown in 2005, Ohio's first placement since 1993. The state has won one special award, Miss Congeniality in 1997. Ohio was one of the last ten states to make their first placement.
Only two Miss Ohio Teen USA titleholders have won the Miss Ohio USA title and competed at Miss USA. The most recent of these is Stacy Offenberger, who placed third runner-up in the Miss USA 2006 pageant.
|Year||Name||Hometown||Age1||Placement at Miss Teen USA||Special awards at Miss Teen USA||Notes|
|1998||Stacy Offenberger||Vincent||Later Miss Ohio USA 2006, 3rd runner up at Miss USA 2006|
|1997||Christina Todd||Miss Congeniality|
|1996||Tara Shaffer||1st runner-up to Miss Ohio USA 2005|
|1991||Michelle Mouser||Later Miss Ohio USA 1997|
|1987||Christy Hoyt||New Concord|