Since this is a nonpartisan special election, all candidates for the election were listed alphabetically, though their party affiliations are noted on the ballot. According to Georgia law, to win outright, a candidate needed a majority vote; since no candidate won more than 50% of the vote, the top two finishers competed in a runoff election on July 17 2007.
Because of the close vote total in the runoff, Whitehead also had the right to request a recount of the runoff result, but chose not to do so.
The official returns for the June 19 election and the July 17 run-off are:
| Candidates | General Election, June 19 | Run-Off Election, July 17 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Candidate | Party | Votes | Percent | Votes | Percent |
| Jim Whitehead | Republican | 23,555 | 43.51% | 23,135 | 49.58% |
| Paul Broun | Republican | 11,208 | 20.70% | 23,529 | 50.42% |
| James Marlow | Democratic | 11,010 | 20.34% | ||
| Denise Freeman | Democratic | 2,574 | 4.76% | ||
| Evita Paschall | Democratic | 1,778 | 3.28% | ||
| Bill Greene | Republican | 1,635 | 3.02% | ||
| Nate Pulliam | Republican | 913 | 1.69% | ||
| Jim Sendelbach | Libertarian | 710 | 1.31% | ||
| Mark Myers | Republican | 378 | 0.70% | ||
| Erik Underwood | Republican | 376 | 0.70% | ||