Self Against City formed in April 2004 in Sacramento, California, when vocalist Jonathan Michael, guitarists Jack Matranga and Jeff LaTour, bassist Patrick O'Connor and drummer Chris Trombley emerged from various local bands such as Amden and Age of Assassins. They immediately realized that the five of them had a great chemistry, so they began writing songs and touring the California area. Their band name originated from Michael hearing radio DJ Marco Collins use the phrase. In restrospect, he is not completely sure whether Marco said "self against city" or "Suffragette City", a song by David Bowie from his album The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars.
The quintet pooled their cash and recorded three songs at Fat Cat Studios in Sacramento, California. The songs were uploaded to their PureVolume profile, a link to which was forwarded to Drive-Thru Records owner Richard Reines (who was at the moment looking for new bands for a subsidiary record label called Rushmore Records) by a fan of the band. He soon approached the band and asked for more material. Upon hearing the songs, Reines invited the band to play a showcase in Los Angeles for him and Drive-Thru co-owner Stefanie Reines. That same night over dinner, the two offered the band a record deal. On November 6 2004, Self Against City officially became the first band to sign to Rushmore Records, only a few months after their formation.
Their first act as a signed band was to record a cover of Darlene Love's "Alone on Christmas" for the Drive-Thru Christmas compilation Happy Holidays from Drive-Thru Records and a sixth song for their debut EP, advance copies of which had been given out at a show at the Boardwalk in Orangevale, California on October 28 2004. Take It How You Want It finally hit music store shelves on April 5 2005, while the band embarked on their first nationwide co-headlining tour with Houston Calls the same month. They hit a total of 32 cities across 18 states. Upon returning home in July, LaTour left the band. Though initially the band made efforts to try and replace LaTour — Blake Abbey of the Daytona Beach, Florida band Abagnale sporadically filled in as a rhythm guitarist — they soon decided to continue on as a four piece and began writing songs for their first full-length record. Two days before the band left for recording in March 2006, LaTour decided to rejoin.
Self Against City began recording their full-length album Telling Secrets to Strangers in April 2006 with producers Steve Haigler and Mike Watts in Long Island, New York. After two weeks of tracking and one week of mixing the album was completed. In June 2006, a month after returning home from recording, O'Connor and Trombley left the band. Drummer Justin Barnes (formerly of Simplistic) officially joined the band in August 2006, two days before the band left for tour with Houston Calls and Quietdrive, while Hunter MacDonald (whom the band met while on tour with JamisonParker temporarily filled in on bass. Towards the end of the year, in search of a new permanent bassist, the group once again recruited fellow vocalist/bassist Blake Abbey, who was announced an official member in December 2006.
From Telling Secrets to Strangers: