A new Algoma district was created from Algoma East and Algoma West in 1966. It consisted of most of Algoma District except the extreme north and northwestern portions, and Sault Ste. Marie. It also included Manitoulin Island, nearby islands, and the southwestern corner of Sudbury. In 1976, the district was expanded to the north, and to include the suburbs of Sault Ste. Marie, Whitefish River Indian Reserve, and more of the southwestern part of Sudbury District.
In 1987, it was expanded to include part of the city of Sault Ste. Marie, the part of Rankin Indian Reserve within city limits, more of western Sudbury District, all of Manitoulin District, and much of southcentral Sudbury District. There were also some boundary changes in the north part of the Algoma district.
In 1996, the district consisted of all of Algoma District except Sault Ste. Marie, the northwestern corner and the southwestern corner of Sudbury District, Manitoulin District, and the southeastern corner of Thunder Bay District.
In 1997, the name of the district was changed to Algoma-Manitoulin.
The riding was abolished in 2003 when it was redistributed into Algoma—Manitoulin—Kapuskasing, Nickel Belt and Sault Ste. Marie ridings.
This riding has elected the following Members of Parliament:
|- |Wemyss Mackenzie Simpson |align="right"| 250 |align="right"| 47.3 |- |William Beatty |align="right"|241 |align="right"| 45.6 |- |Mr. MacDonell |align="right"|38 |align="right"| 7.2 |}
On Mr. Simpson's resignation to become Indian Commissioner for the North: |- |CUMBERLAND, Frederick William |align="right"| acclaimed |}
|- |ROBINSON, Hon. John Beverly |align="right"|300 |- |DENISON, G.J. Junr. |align="right"|219 |}
|- |BORRON, Edward Barron |align="right"| 436 |- |SCOTT, W.J. |align="right"|258 |- |BROWN, P.J. |align="right"|18 |}
|- |DAWSON, Simon James |align="right"| 885 |- |RANKIN, |align="right"|480 |}
|- |DAWSON, Simon James |align="right"| 1,707 |- |MCDOUGALL, Wm. |align="right"|1,112 |}
|- |DAWSON, S.J. |align="right"| 1,428 |- |BURK, D.F. |align="right"| 1,410 |}
|- |MACDONELL, Geo. H. |align="right"| 2,251 |- |BURK, Daniel F. |align="right"| 1,813 |}
|- |DYMENT, A.E. |align="right"| 3,176 |- |MACDONELL, G.H. |align="right"| 1,349 |}
|- |DYMENT, A.E. |align="right"| 3,083 |- |BOYCE, A.C. |align="right"|2,724 |}
|- |FOSTER, Maurice |align="right"|9,542 |- |MCPHAIL, John D. |align="right"| 5,270 |- |LEFEBVRE, Len |align="right"| 4,057 |}
|- |FOSTER, Maurice |align="right"|10,160 |- |BURLEY, Dale |align="right"| 6,721 |- |SWEENEY, Kelly |align="right"|4,599 |- |COTE, Nil F. |align="right"|508 |- |STRAIN, George Washington |align="right"|150 |}
|- |FOSTER, Maurice |align="right"|11,360 |- |MACDONALD, Hughene |align="right"|5,240 |- |RITCHIE, Ron |align="right"|5,136 |- |TROTTIER, Fernand |align="right"|100 |}
|- |FOSTER, Maurice |align="right"| 15,277 |- |DINNER, Jim |align="right"| 10,989 |- |SAGLE, Fred |align="right"| 7,531 |- |DERRAH, Wayne |align="right"|121 |}
|- |FOSTER, Maurice |align="right"|17,432 |- |DINNER, Jim |align="right"|11,262 |- |GILBERTSON, Bernt |align="right"|5,633 |- |REID, Leslie T. |align="right"|113 |- |GREY, David |align="right"| 49 |}
|- |FOSTER, Maurice |align="right"|14,113 |- |REED, Jim |align="right"| 12,811 |- |FRANGIONE, Rocco |align="right"| 9,499 |- |BRUZAS, Harold |align="right"|462 |}
|- |FOSTER, Maurice |align="right"|16,766 |- |REED, Jim heating |align="right"|7,383 |- |GREENSPOON, Lloyd |align="right"|7,341 |}
|- |ST. DENIS, Brent |align="right"| 18,218 |- |LEFFLER, Ken |align="right"| 6,623 |- |MAIR, David |align="right"|3,614 |- |BROAD, Gayle Erma |align="right"| 2,695 |- |BRÉGAINT, Bernard |align="right"|235 |}
|- |ST. DENIS, Brent |align="right"| 13,810 |- |JEFFERY, Jim |align="right"| 8,353 |- |WILDMAN, Jody |align="right"| 7,897 |- |MACDONALD, Roseanne |align="right"| 3,367 |}
|- |ST. DENIS, Brent |align="right"| 15,000 |- |SWAIN, Ron |align="right"| 8,992 |- |BUCK, Grant |align="right"| 4,326 |- |LAPHAM, Dale |align="right"| 2,269 |- |JABLANCZY, Alexander |align="right"| 428 |}